CoreCougars.com
  • CoreCougars.com
    • The Origins of Education and Mandatory Schooling
  • Research
    • Attorney Nathan MacPherson and MORE
    • Common Core is iLLEGAL - Your Proof
    • Comments
    • Conspiracy Plot by Anita Hoge >
      • Common Core Face-Off: Hiding the Truth About Choice and Charter Schools
      • Anita Hoge & Charlotte Iserbyt
    • Data Collection
    • Educational >
      • Don Allen - Common Core Condensed
      • Samuel L. Blumenfeld
      • Chinese Multiplication
      • James Clavell
      • Common Core Developmentally Inappropriate >
        • Childhood Development
        • Common Core Standards Are NOT Developmentally Appropriate
        • Dr. Megan Koschnick Child Clinical Psychologist - Common Core is Developmentally Inappropriate
        • Jean Piaget on Cognitive Stages of Development >
          • The origins of intelligence in children .pdf by Jean Piaget
          • Jean Piaget Books
          • Jean Piaget’s Theory
          • Piaget's stages of cognitive development
      • John Denver
      • Norman Dodds
      • Karen R. Effrem, MD
      • Michael P. Farris, Esq.
      • Dr. Rudolf Flesch
      • John Taylor Gatto
      • G Edward Griffin
      • Anita Hoge
      • Charlotte Thomson Iserbyt
      • Heide Marvin Janshon‎
      • Dr. James Milgram
      • Dr. Alison Rampersad
      • Clint Richardson >
        • Clint Richardson
        • Banks: Are they really the bad guys?
        • The Organic Laws of The United States of America
        • United States of America, U.S. Incorporated
        • George Washington Jailer And Tax Collector
      • Dr. Ed Rivera
      • Dr. Sandra Stotsky
      • JaKell Sullivan
      • Dr. Gary Thompson
      • Kitty Werthman
      • Lily Tang Williams
      • WiFi in School KILLING Children?
    • FLORIDA DOE School District Superintendents LIST
    • Homeschooling >
      • Global Support - Freedom Project Education FPEUSA.org
      • Homeschooling vs Public School
      • Homeschool Laws & Legalities
      • Learning Resources >
        • Learning Resources Store
      • Parental Rights and Responsibilities Act of 95 H.R. 1946 S. 984
      • The Blumenfeld Education Letter
      • The Christian Homeschool Oasis
    • Gates Notes >
      • Gates Notes 2015
    • Know Your Rights
    • NEA
    • NewsWithViews.com >
      • Anita Hoge
      • Kelleigh Nelson
      • Dr. Laurie Roth Ph.D.
    • Other >
      • Alice Linahan and Bethany Blankley
      • Boycott Supporters of Common Core
      • Common Core - A Message to the Orange County Board of Education
      • Common Core ties to Libya, Qatar, Saudi Arabia
      • FL Parents R.I.S.E. >
        • FL’S COMMON CORE POLITICAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST
      • Richard Andrew Grove >
        • Freedom Force International
        • Richard Andrew Grove
        • Our World in Balance
        • Tragedy and Hope
      • How To Win Friends And Influence People - Dale Carnegie - Audiobook Full
      • Muckety
      • Parent Advocate Central NY Board of Ed Meeting
      • States >
        • Florida >
          • Florida Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on Education
          • Dixie County, FL
          • Lee County, FL
        • New York >
          • Ichabod Crane Central School District
        • Oklahoma >
          • Oklahoma Repealing Common Core
    • Washington Times Column Claims Common Core Is Islamic Infiltration Of America
    • What is RTI a/k/a MTSS
  • Common Core
    • Article Archives
    • Randy E. Barnett
    • Common Core Public License
    • Bloggers - Common Core >
      • EDUCATIONALCHEMY
      • Freedom Project
      • Missouri Education Watchdog
    • Common Core FACTS
    • Common Core Standards for Mathematics
    • Cscope >
      • 2013-14 Texas Curriculum Management Program Cooperative – TEKS Resource System
      • Texax Curriculum Management Program Cooperative
      • Texas Drops “Anti-American” CSCOPE Lessons; Battle Continues
      • Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills Website
    • Data Collection - FLORIDA >
      • AIR - American Institutes for Research
      • Articles on Data Collections
      • Common Core means the government is collecting 300 data elements about students, says anti-Common Core activist
      • Hillsborough County Schools Student Data Collection
      • University of Florida Information Privacy Policies and Procedures 2012
      • What are the 400 Data Points Questions?
    • EDUCATIONALCHEMY
    • FACEBOOK - Common Core Groups >
      • Facebook Groups Regarding Common Core
      • Common Core
      • Common Core Books
      • Common Core Classes 3 and 4
      • Common Core Community Meeting
      • Common Core Content
      • Common Core Forum for Teachers
      • Common Core is Child Abuse
      • Common Core Meeting
      • Common Core Task-Based Middle Grades Math
      • COMMON CORE TRAINING
      • Concerned Parents against Common Core (CPACC)
      • CURE-Citizens United for Responsible Education
      • Deer Park Parents Against Common Core!
      • Eastern WA Parents and Taxpayers Against Common Core
      • Freedom From Educational Tyranny
      • Freeman Parents Investigating Common Core
      • Georgia wants Common Core OUT!!
      • Hicksville Parents Against Common Core
      • Iron County Against Common Core
      • MAD - Moms Against Duncan
      • New Jersey Against Common Core
      • No More Common Core
      • Parents Against Common Core
      • Stop Common Core
      • Stop Common Core in New Milford CT
      • Stop Common Core in Rochester
      • Stop Sen. Lehner & Common Core
      • Texans AGAINST COMMON CORE
      • Video Blast! Tell Your Common Core Story!
      • Webster County Against Common Core- WCACC
      • What is common core? Why STOP IT at all cost?
    • Flow Charts Following the Common Core Money
    • Recommended Reading >
      • 3 must-read books on the Constitution: recommendations from chief architect of the Obamacare challenge Randy Barnett
    • Schools >
      • American Education with Common Core Documentation
      • Charters Schools USA
      • HERITAGE FOUNDATION, NAFTA, SCHOOL CHOICE AND THE DESTRUCTION OF TRADITIONAL EDUCATION
      • IB programmes
      • International Baccalaureate (IB) Unraveled
      • International Baccalaureate (IB) Schools
      • International Baccalaureate is Anti-American & Anti-Christian?
      • International Baccalaureate (IB) Programs Are being Adopted In K-12 Public Schools Throughout The U.S.
      • Charlotte Iserbyt "Common Core" a trojan horse. Project exposes the educ fraud
      • The Global Road To Ruin Through Education – Iserbyt
    • School Choice
    • Special Ed Advocates to Stop Common Core >
      • Special Ed Advocates to Stop Common Core
    • Florida >
      • Central Florida "Florida Parents Against Common Core" (FPACC) Facebook Group
      • Florida Parents Against Common Core and Race to the Top Website
      • Florida Stop Common Core Coalition Website
      • Floridians Against Common Core Education Website
      • Northeast Florida Parents Against Common Core Facebook Page
      • Stop Common Core in Florida NOW Website
    • Idaho >
      • Idahoans Against Common Core Facebook Page
      • Idahoans for Local Education Website
      • Stop Common Core in Idaho Facebook Page
    • Indiana >
      • Hoosiers Against Common Core Facebook Page
      • Hoosiers Against Common Core Website
    • Stop Common Core in Washington State
    • TESTS
    • The Federal Hand Behind Common Core
    • Videos - Common Core >
      • A teacher describes why she left teaching in public schools... Common Core
      • Afterburner with Bill Whittle: The Cookie Cutter Curriculum by PJ Media
      • Agenda 21 EXPLAINED, full version
      • Arkansas Mother Obliterates Common Core in 4 Minutes!
      • BUILDING THE MACHINE - The Common Core Documentary
      • Classical Education vs. Common Core by Kevin Ritter
      • George Carlin They Don't Give a Fu@k About You
      • Common Core: Based on UN Agenda 21, UNESCO Standards
      • Common Core: Dangers And Threats To American Liberty And Education
      • CPS Teacher Professional Development from CEO's Network by ChiEd Justice
      • Faces of Common Core
      • FiscalRangersFlorida >
        • David Barton - Why Common Core is a Failure - March 22, 2014 Orlando, FL
        • Laura Caruso - opposition to Florida Common Core
        • Common Core Opposition Panel Discussion - Operation Education March 22, 2014
        • Common Core Presentation by Laura Caruso at Women Impacting the Nation meeting Nov. 11, 2013
        • Florida Sen Alan Hays on Common Core after CC Presentation
        • Stephen D. Guschov, Esq.
      • Indoctrination in Public Schools - The Call to Dunkirk
      • “Listen: The Movie” challenging the culture of standardized testing
      • Planned Illiteracy
      • Public "Education" has become indoctrination and distraction
      • Andrew Pudewa - Oklahoma Common Core Interim Study November 5, 2013
      • Something Is Rotten in the Denver Airport
      • Teachers Bash Common Core at Forum.. WAVE 3
      • Teachers Want Common Core Standards Gone Too
      • The Dark Intentions of Public Schooling
      • The Origins of the American Public Education System: Horace Mann & the Prussian Model of Obedience
      • The Shocking Truth About Public Schools
      • The War on Kids: The Definitive Documentary on the Failure of the Public Education System
      • Walking the Labyrinth of the Corporate-Owned-Common Core by Morna McDermott
      • York912 April 4, 2013
    • Websites - Common Core >
      • EDUCATIONALCHEMY
      • Florida Parents Against Common Core and Race to the Top
      • Patriot Journalist
    • What are RP Tests or Reading Practice Tests? by Renaissance Learning, Inc.
  • Take Action
    • What Can YOU Do?
    • Government >
      • Legislative Process
      • Senators >
        • Lamar Alexander
      • Senators on Twitter
  • HCPS BLOG
  • More...
    • A News Reporter >
      • a News Reporter
      • Agenda 21 EXPOSED
      • Buses
      • Money Mafia and the UFO Cabal - Major Revelations! Former Defense Minister Paul Hellyer
      • New World Order
      • Plant City School Lockdown
      • pvc chicken tractor
    • William Baer's Story
    • Charter Schools >
      • Florida charter schools: big money, little oversight
      • National Conference of State Legislatures NCSL
      • Trinity School for Children
    • Cork Cougars
    • FERPA
    • Hillsborough County, FL >
      • Auditors Hillsborough County School Board
      • Hillsborough County, Florida School List in
      • Hillsborough County Public Schools Telephone Directory
      • Hillsborough County SPECIAL TEACHERS ARE REWARDED STAR Teacher Performance Assessment Evaluation Information
      • Hillsborough County Student Incidents
      • Alberto Carvalho
      • April Griffin
      • Jeb Bush
      • MaryEllen Elia
      • Sally Harris
      • Susan L. Valdes Resignation
      • Susan Valdes
      • Valerie Chuchman
    • How School Came to Be
    • Knowledgeworks
    • Measurement Inc.
    • Carlos Morales
    • OPT OUT >
      • 2014 Florida Statutes
      • OPT OUT ORLANDO
      • Student Privacy Matters
    • PEARSON - PARCC
    • Pearson Center for Applied Psychometric Research
    • Reading Instructions >
      • A Systematic, Multisensory Phonics Reading Program with K-2 Language Arts
      • Florida Center for Reading Research Orton-Gillingham Approach Dyslexia
      • Multisensory Structured Language Programs: Content and Principles of Instruction
      • Orton-Gillingham Power Point Presentation
      • Orton Gillingham Approach on Pinterest
      • ORTON-GILLINGHAM-BASED AND/OR MULTISENSORY STRUCTURED LANGUAGE APPROACHES
      • Orton-Gillingham Resource Catalog
      • Reading Assessment for Orton Gillingham and Phonics Based Programs
      • Peds to Pinterest
      • The Gillingham Manual
      • Word Families Flip Chart
      • Writing with Orton-Gillingham Pinterest
    • FreeMen Burt >
      • Only FreeMen
      • ARMS NOT FIREARMS
      • Matt Damon on Civil Disobedience
      • First video how to become Free updated_0001.wmv
      • Florida Charter School Alliance Program
      • Freedom Basics #1
      • GET OUT OF JAIL CARD Part 1_0001.wmv
      • GET OUT OF JAIL CARD Part 2_0001.wmv
      • Gnostic Media – Interview with Freeman Burt and Kim
      • GPO - America's Authentic Government Information
      • JAIL CARD part 3.wmv
      • LEARNING INFORMATION AND TOOLS
      • PREPARING TO BE HELPED
      • Reading Lists
      • The Art of War Sun Tsu Full Documentary
      • The Greatest Speech Ever - Charlie Chaplin - The Great Dictator
      • The public school arithmetic
      • The Truth About Slavery: Past, Present and Future
      • Two-Thirds of Americans Live in the 4th Amendment “Exemption Zone”
      • Howard Zinn
      • 6th video_0001.wmv Jurisdiction
      • 7th video-JURISDICTION- Part 2-14TH AMENDMENT
Reading Lists 

Middle School Reading Lists 100 Years Ago Vs. Today
Submitted by Annie Holmquist on Thu, 09/18/2014 - 10:49
Source


Picture
I recently dug up a 1908 curriculum manual in the Minnesota Historical Society archives. It provided instructions on everything from teacher deportment to recommended literature lists for various grades. As a book lover, I was especially interested in the latter!

With the exception of a few textbook-like anthologies, the chart below lists the recommended reading material for Minnesota 7th and 8th graders in 1908:

Picture
With such a list in hand, I decided to examine if the common accusation that today’s education standards have been dumbed down is really true. To make sure I wasn’t unfairly weighting this survey in favor of the past, I went to one of the Twin Cities metro area's finest districts, namely, Edina Public Schools. Again, with the exception of a few textbook anthologies, the list below offers the reading options for their 7th and 8th grade students:
Picture
In examining these lists, I noticed three important differences between the reading content of these two eras:

1. Time Period

One of the striking features of the Edina list is how recent the titles are. Many of the selections were published in the 21st century. In fact, only four of the selections are more than 20 years old.

In comparison, over half of the titles on the first list were at least 20 years old in 1908, with many of them averaging between 50 to 100 years old.

Older is not necessarily better, but the books on the first list suggest that schools of the past were more likely to give their students time-tested, classic literature, rather than books whose popularity may happen to be a passing fad.

2. Thematic Elements

A second striking difference between the two book lists are the themes they explore. The first is full of historical references and settings which stretch from ancient Greece (Tanglewood Tales) to the Middle Ages (Harold, Last of Saxon Kings) to the founding of America (Courtship of Miles Standish). Through highly recognized authors such as Longfellow, Stevenson, Kipling, and Dickens, these titles introduce children to a vast array of themes crucial to understanding the foundations upon which America and western civilization were built.

The Edina list, however, largely deals with modern history, particularly hitting on many current political and cultural themes such as the Taliban (The Breadwinner), cloning, illegal immigrants, the drug war (The House of the Scorpion), and deeply troubled youth (Touching Spirit Bear). In terms of longstanding, classic authors, Mark Twain and Ray Bradbury are the only ones who stand out.

It’s good for children to understand the world in which they live, but as with any area in life, you can have too much of a good thing. A continual focus on modern literature narrows the lens through which children can view and interpret the world. Would it not be better to broaden their horizons and expose them to a balance of both old and new literature?

3. Reading Level

Many of the books on the Edina list use fairly simple, understandable language and vocabulary familiar to the modern reader. Consider the first paragraph ofNothing But the Truth:

“Coach Jamison saw me in the hall and said he wanted to make sure I’m trying out for the track team!!!! Said my middle school gym teacher told him I was really good!!!! Then he said that with me on the Harrison High team we have a real shot at being county champs. Fantastic!!!!!! He wouldn’t say that unless he meant it. Have to ask folks about helping me get new shoes. Newspaper route won’t do it all. But Dad was so excited when I told him what Coach said that I’m sure he’ll help.”

On the other hand, consider the first paragraph of Longfellow’s Evangeline:

"This is the forest primeval. The murmuring pines and the hemlocks,
Bearded with moss, and in garments green, indistinct in the twilight,
Stand like Druids of eld, with voices sad and prophetic,
Stand like harpers hoar, with beards that rest on their bosoms.
Loud from its rocky caverns, the deep-voiced neighboring ocean
Speaks, and in accents disconsolate answers the wail of the forest."

The first example uses simple words and a casual sentence structure, while the second uses a rich vocabulary and a complex writing format. Naturally, some might look at the second selection and say, “Good grief! How do you expect a child to understand that?!?”

But that’s the whole point. Unless we give our students challenging material to dissect, process, and study, how can we expect them to break out of the current poor proficiency ratings and advance beyond a basic reading level?

My takeaway from this comparison? It's great that schools today have students read contemporary literature. But we still need to make sure that students also read good literature from the past and are sufficiently challenged.

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.